PG Roast: challenge the idea before reviewing the code
Designing an adversarial proposal reviewer, a CommitFest Shortlist, and evidence-first feedback that saves committer time.
Nik Samokhvalov, Kirk Wolak, and Andrey Borodin explored PG Roast: an adversarial reviewer that asks whether a Postgres proposal is worth accepting before examining its implementation. The call connected precedent-backed objections and practical testing with a curated CommitFest Shortlist, expert routing, and shorter human-owned mailing-list replies. The agreed pilot starts privately on Andrey’s own CommitFest patches. These are discussion notes and proposed work, not evidence that the complete system has shipped.
Summary from session notes; timecodes pending captions.
direct mapping